Comparing Safety: Gas Fireplaces vs. Wood Burning Fireplaces

Firewood safety

Safety should be at the top of your list of considerations when adding a fireplace to your home. Gas and wood-burning fireplaces provide a cosy, inviting atmosphere to any home. Still, the safety of each type of fireplace differs significantly, with their ease of use, low maintenance, and greater safety. 


However, wood-burning fireplaces also have unique benefits that make them popular. By comparing the safety features of each type of fireplace, you can make an informed decision on which would be the best fit for your home. In addition, you can look up firewood suppliers online to help you with your questions.

Overview of safety concerns with gas and wood-burning fireplaces


Both gas and wood-burning fireplaces can be dangerous if not properly maintained. Still, gas fireplaces have several safety features that make them less susceptible to accidents than wood-burning fireplaces. Wood-burning fireplaces are known for causing a significant number of house fires every year. 

While every fireplace poses some risk, it’s essential to understand the potential dangers associated with each type of fireplace and take the proper precautions to reduce the risk of accidents in your home. Fire hazards are one of the biggest concerns with gas and wood-burning fireplaces.

Wood stoves, particularly those with an open flame, pose a significant fire risk and should only be used in well-ventilated areas. With wood-burning fireplaces, sparks and creosote buildup are the two most considerable fire hazards. Sparks from burning wood are a leading cause of house fires, and less-than-ideal conditions can easily lead to sparks igniting nearby flammable materials. 

If unchecked, creosote buildup can also pose a fire hazard, as it can ignite nearby materials. However, sparks and creosote can be minimised by regularly cleaning the fireplace and using a fireplace screen.

Comparison of safety features:

Gas fireplaces

The main advantage of gas fireplaces is that they produce very little smoke, soot, or odour compared to wood-burning fireplaces. Due to their clean-burning properties, gas fireplace emissions do not pose the same indoor air quality concerns as wood-burning fireplaces. 

Gas fireplace emissions only pose a risk if the gas is improperly vented. Gas fireplaces also have an automatic shut-off in case the fire gets too hot, which is helpful if a blockage in the chimney or the fireplace is misused. 

Additionally, they are less susceptible to fuel shortages due to weather conditions than natural gas-powered appliances, such as stoves and water heaters.

Wood-burning fireplaces

Wood-burning fireplaces provide a more natural ambience than gas fireplaces and do not produce carbon monoxide, which is a significant advantage. Wood-burning fireplaces are also more cost-effective, as the fuel source (commonly wood shavings) is significantly less expensive than electricity or natural gas. 

Wood-burning fireplaces also provide a more bonding experience, as they are often a group activity in which friends and family gather to roast meat and vegetables. Wood-burning fireplaces do have a few disadvantages compared to gas fireplaces, though. 

Wood-burning fireplaces produce more pollution and indoor air quality risks than gas fireplaces due to their high particulate matter and carbon monoxide emissions. 

Wood-burning fireplaces also require more maintenance than gas fireplaces, as they produce more soot and creosote and must be cleaned more often. 

You should also burn firewood that is dried and well-seasoned. It is suggested to source your firewood supply from a trusted local firewood supplier such as Black Forest Firewood. Having high-quality firewood can lessen possible risks. If you want to buy firewood online, check our website for an easy transaction process. Our website includes all the details you need to know about making an informed firewood purchase.

Advantages of gas fireplaces

Since gas fireplaces are cleaner and produce fewer emissions than wood-burning fireplaces, they can help improve indoor air quality in homes. Additionally, gas fireplaces only require regular maintenance beyond yearly cleaning and inspection. 

On the other hand, Wood-burning fireplaces require regular maintenance, such as cleaning and creating an airway in the chimney, to minimise the risk of fires and reduce the amount of creosote buildup. 

Gas fireplaces can also be turned on or off at the click of a button, while wood-burning fireplaces must be tended to and monitored throughout the entire burning process. 

With a gas fireplace, there is no need to stand in front of it and watch the flames to ensure they don’t get out of control. Instead, you can safely enjoy the fireplace from another part of the room.

Advantages of wood-burning fireplaces

Wood-burning fireplaces provide a more natural ambience than gas fireplaces, as they do not produce carbon monoxide and use wood shavings as fuel. 

The main advantage of wood-burning fireplaces is that they are cheaper than gas fireplaces and do not require electricity, making them more reliable than gas fireplaces during power outages. 

They also produce fewer emissions than gas fireplaces and do not require a dedicated gas line, which can be costly to install. If you are looking for a firewood supplier, you might want to check Black Forest Firewood. We offer different services that you can also avail of. 

Tips for maintaining a safe fireplace

Here are a few tips for maintaining a safe fireplace

  • Install a smoke detector in your home – The primary concern with wood-burning fireplaces is indoor air quality. Particulate matter emissions can cause significant indoor air quality issues, such as irritation and allergic reactions. Install a smoke detector in the room where you plan to use the fireplace to ensure that it is properly vented and that there is no excessive particulate matter buildup. 
  • Choose the right fuel source – The type of fuel you use in your fireplace can significantly affect indoor air quality and fire risk. Hardwoods, such as ironbark and maple, are a good choice for outdoor fire pits and indoor fireplaces, as they have low emissions and are less likely to cause fires. However, other types of wood, such as pine, have a high oil content, which can produce significant indoor air quality issues. 
  • Clean your fireplace regularly – Cleaning your fireplace regularly can help reduce creosote buildup and the risk of fires. You can clean your fireplace with either a vacuum or a fireplace brush.


Shopping cart
There are no products in the cart!
Continue shopping